Click our Site Map link at the top of the page to navigate the features of the site.

2005 Top 5 Running Back Keepers

The Sandman - February 14, 2005


The 2004 season is over so it is time to start looking at 2005 and beyond. For those of you who play in keeper leagues, I will have a serious of articles that are geared to analyzing players who should be kept for next year and beyond. Just to level set everyone; I look for my starting running back to average 120 total yards and a touchdown. If I can get that on a week-in-and-week-out basis then I consider my running back productive.
 


5. Kevin Jones – Detroit Lions (16 games, 1,313 yards and 5 touchdowns)

Analysis – Jones was given the starting job the day he was drafted but it took awhile before the coaching staff had the confidence to use him on a consistent basis. When they finally let him loose in week 11, he met my standard for a productive back.  Over his last 7 games he averaged 133 total yards and had 4 of his 5 touchdowns.

2005 Prediction – Jones still needs to work on certain aspects of his game. He has the skills to be an elite running back but he needs a better quarterback to take some of the pressure off of him.  I think he will have 1,600 yards and at least 10 touchdowns next year.

Beyond 2005 – If the Lions develop a solid passing game Jones could be the next Emmitt Smith.  If they don’t then he will become the next Barry Sanders, lots of yards but a limited number of touchdowns.
 


4. Julius Jones - Dallas Cowboys (8 games, 928 yards and 7 touchdowns)

Analysis – Jones plays for a hall-of-fame coach who loves to run the ball. That makes him a keeper in my book. Jones’ overall numbers don’t look that great but you have to remember that he didn’t play in 8 games. He had a DNP in week one and he missed six weeks with a shoulder injury.  Upon his return, he was great (81, 150, 198, 88, 80, 57 and 149 yards rushing). He is clearly the player Bill Parcells thought he could be and when Parcells has a horse like this he will ride him.

2005 Prediction – Jones' development will continue and Parcells will force him to learn the blitz pickup.  This will get him on the field more often and should allow for additional yards via the pass.  Jones should easily get 1,500 yards and 12 touchdowns next year.

Beyond 2005 – Jones will be next Curtis Martin, another running back who benefited from coach Parcells tutelage
 


3. Shaun Alexander – Seattle Seahawks (16 games, 1,864 yards and 20 touchdowns)

Analysis – Alexander was the No.1 fantasy back in 2004.  For that reason alone he is an automatic keeper.  When you take a look at his career you will see a very solid and consistent running back.  He has averaged 4.4 yards per carry over his five-year career but he has never had a year that he has averaged more than 4.9.  The thing I like about him is that he has played in every game since he was drafted 5 years ago.  In an age when there a specialty backs, Alexander plays on all downs, in all situations.  At 225 pounds he is a power back who has no problem carrying the ball 300+ times.

2005 Prediction – Alexander will be Alexander. When you look back on the season you should see 1,625 yards and 15+ touchdowns.  The only concern I have is that he might end up on another team.  He is going to be a free agent and switching teams is always a risk for any running back (see Clinton Portis).

Beyond 2005 – Alexander is still relatively young, 27, but it is rare that a running back's career goes 10+ years.  I don’t expect him to be the No.1 overall back again but he should be solid for another three or four years.
 .


2. Willis McGahee – Buffalo Bills (16 games, 1,297 yards and 13 touchdowns)

Analysis – McGahee’s year was so good that it’s hard to believe he didn’t become a starter until week 6.  Once he was named the starter he showed why he was a No.1 pick in 2003.  He started 12 games and had 7 100-yard rushing games.  If you take out the first fours weeks and multiply his numbers so that they equal a full season, you get 1,500+ yards and 16 touchdowns.  That would have ranked him 4th last year.  He needs to work on his blitz pickup so that he can remain on the field on 3rd down but that will come with time.

2005 Prediction – McGahee should be a top-five running back next year.  He will be the perfect back for those owners who grab a quarterback or wide receiver in the first round. I expect 1,500 yards and 15 touchdowns but that could be on the conservative side.

Beyond 2005 – McGahee will be a fantasy stud within the next two years.
 


1. LaDanian Tomlinson – San Diego Chargers (15 games, 1,776 yards and 18 touchdowns)

Analysis – It is amazing what a quarterback can do to a team's overall offense. The development of Drew Brees forced teams play the pass and this helped the running game. What I love about Tomlinson is his consistency.  He had 100-yard games in 10 of the 15 games he played in.  For most of the five other games, he only played a half since he was nursing a hamstring injury and the Chargers had big leads.  The bonus you get with Tomlinson is his receiving yards, 4th amongst running backs with 441 yards.  One more thing, the Chargers play in the AFC West.  This division had 2 of the 3 worst defenses in the NFL last year.

2005 Prediction – This is the year that Tomlinson becomes the No.1 overall fantasy back.  He has flirted will this ranking in the past but the Chargers are on the rise and Tomlinson will be the main beneficiary.  Don’t be surprised if he has 2,000 combined yards and 20 touchdowns.

Beyond 2005 – Tomlinson has only played for four years. Since he is so flexible, he should continue to be a top-three fantasy back for the next five years.
 


So that is it, my top-five running back keepers for 2005 and beyond.  All of you Priest Holmes fans can start emailing me, but the knee injuries put up a huge red flag to me and he has two in the last three years.

 - The Sandman

 


NFLFreaks Home | Game Prep | Game Focus | Player Performance Predictions | Start-Bench List | The Line 

 Player News | Draft Central | Fantasy Features | Freak Of the Week | Hall of Shame | Ask the Freaks | NFL Statistics

 NFL Standings | NFL Schedule |  Fantasy Resources | NFL Team Links | Local Newspapers | Fantasy Site Links


 

We want to publish the best, most complete and authoritative site on the internet.  What do you want to see?  Email us at Our Users Make the Call to get your thoughts, comments and suggestions about the site.

Are you getting strange error messages?  Are any of the java controls not displaying (i.e. big, gray boxes appearing)?  Are you having trouble with pages loading slowly or pages not displaying at all?  Whatever trouble you may be having, we want to know about it.  For problems or questions regarding this web site please contact NFLFreaks Support.

NFLFreaks.com is not in any way affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the National Football League (NFL), any NFL team or any National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) members.           

© Copyright 1998-2005 NFLFreaks.com. All rights reserved.